Brent, this used to be less of a problem, but recent case law suggests that requiring counseling now may be the equivalent of requiring a medical examination. This means there can be implications under the Americans with Disabilities Act. Requiring counseling would then have to be “job-related and consistent with business necessity.”
This new standard could impact missions in two areas.
- First, what are their spiritual and moral standards? They may be able to require counseling as a corrective for problems that violate the spiritual and moral standards (which should be clearly defined in advance).
- Second, what responsibilities does the mission have to care for people in remote or dangerous areas, both for the individual and for others on the team? This may necessitate requiring counseling, and also should be clearly defined in advance.
As religious organizations, missions are going to have a bit more freedom than secular organizations to require counseling. In many cases, the worker won’t even be able to bring in the ADA because the ministerial exception gives the mission complete discretion over employment decisions. But the wiser approach (and kinder to employees) is to avoid these problems by having consistent and well-implemented policies.
Disclaimer: not official legal or psychological advice or opinion
- Criminal Records and Convictions: What an Employer Should or Should Not Do When Hiring Employees
- Can You Fire An Employee in Colorado For Using Marijuana?
- New NLRB Guidance on Employee Handbook Policies Provides Greater Flexibility for Employers
- Colorado Employer Update: 2018 Legislative Session in Review
- Verified Volunteers: A Background Check Option